CLOSED 4/26-5/4. All emails will be answered on 5/5. Thank you

  • Home
  • About the Bake Shop
    • Our Story
  • Menu
  • Contact the Baker

Menu / Price List

Cookies

MOM Flower Pot Set

20

You pick the flower color- yellow, pink or purple?

Pickup 5/10 12-4pm

Custom Sugar Cookies

$55+

Tier One: 2-3 shapes, up to three colors. Basic design, minimal airbrushing. $58 per dozen

Tier Two: 3-4 shapes, up to five colors, some airbrushing, more elaborate design, metallics, including custom logo $62 per dozen

Tier Three: Up to six shapes, 5+ colors, airbrushing, intricate design (including florals, character cookies), airbrushing, use of metallics, sparkles, luster dust $65 per dozen

Minimum of one dozen and 14 days notice

Flavors: Vanilla, Almond, Chocolate, Pumpkin Spice, Lemon

Key Lime Pie Bars

3 / $10

The Perfect Summer Treat

Boston Cream Pie Cookies

4 / $16

Coconut Cream Pie Cookie

4 / $16

Chocolate Mint

4 / $20

Cinnaswirl Cookies

6 for $20

A jumbo, soft cinnamon vanilla snickerdoodle-esque cookie topped with sweet, tangy cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar

Milkshake Cookies

$20 / dozen

A soft vanilla sugar cookie rolled in sprinkles topped with ”milkshake” buttercream

DYO Kit

$28

Perfect birthday treat & activity! Eight cookies, your choice of three icing colors, and two sprinkle options

Keeping It Classy

$17 / dozen

Timeless classic made with semi sweet and milk chocolate chips

Chocolate Oatie

$24 / dozen

Oatmeal cookie packed with semi sweet chocolate chunks

DAIRY FREE Chocolate Oatie

$26 / dozen

The most popular chocolate chip oatmeal cookie made sans dairy

Coffee Oreo Cookie

4 for $18

A coffee base dough with Oreo pieces mixed in, along with dark chocolate, stuffed with Oreo in the middle

Snickerdoodle

$17 / dozen

Cinnamon vanilla dough rolled in cinnamon sugar. These are soft and thick, not flat and crunchy.

Oatmeal Cream Pie

4 for $14

A soft molasses cookie with fluffy vanilla cream filling

Mellow Oreo

4 for $18

Cookies n cream base with white chocolate chips, marshmallow and stuffed with Oreo

Chewy Gingersnaps

$17 / dozen

Chewy brown sugar and molasses cookie with cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg rolled in sugar

Pecan Sandies

$17 / dozen

A salty, buttery cookie filled with pecans, and rolled in sugar for sweetness

Island Vibe Cookie

$19 / dozen

Vanilla cookie loaded with white chocolate chips, coconut, and pieces of macadamia nuts. White chocolate can be substituted with semi sweet or milk chocolate if white chocolate is not your jam

Almond Cookie

$24 / dozen

Chewy almond cookie topped with sliced almonds

Fleur de Sel

$30 / dozen

Chocolate cookie sprinkled with dark chocolate & semi sweet chips, stuffed with a homemade salted caramel and topped with sea salt  

Choctopia Cookie

$19 / dozen

Rich chocolate cookie made with organic cocoa powder, semi sweet, milk, and dark chocolate chips

PYO Cookie

$7 Each

Makes an awesome party favor or holiday party activity. Contact baker for design options

Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies

$16 / dozen

Reese Campfire

$28 / dozen

Famous campfire cookie stuffed with milk chocolate and Reese's

"Raisin" the Roof Cookie

$24 / dozen

Tall spiced oatmeal cookie loaded with sweet raisins

Campfire Cookie

$26 / dozen

Graham cracker base, milk chocolate chunks, and marshmallows 

Tricky Treat Cookie (SEASOAL- Sept. - Nov.

4 for $20

Intensely flavored chocolate cookie with two Reese PB Cups and chocolate chunks

Apple Crisp Cookie

4 for $17

Spiced oatmeal cookie stuffed with apples and topped with brown sugar oat crisp. These cookies make amazing favors for Autumn weddings or seasonal events  

"Get Well Soon" Cookies

$22

A unique treat for someone who could use a "pick me up" or a "Thank You" for a healthcare worker. Bring a smile to someone's face. Each bag contains 15 mini cookies. Colors may vary.

Brown Butter Brownies

4 for $16

Rich & fudge

Raspberry Oat Bars

6 / $15

Lemon Bar

6 / $20

A soft shortbread topped to zesty, sweet lemon goodness, topped with powdered sugar

Seven Layer Bars

4 / $16

Sweet and salty graham crust topped with butterscotch chips, coconut, pecans, semi sweet chocolate 


Rolls, Breakfast & Pies, oh my!

Chocolate Whoopie Pies

4 for $16

Chocolate cake made with organic cocoa  powder, sandwiched in between fluffy, vanilla frosting

Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies

4 for $18

The chocolate whoopie pie with peanut butter filling

Pumpkin Whoopie Pie

4 for $20

A Fall favorite! Pumpkin spice cake with the only kind of filling that should be in a pumpkin whoopie!

Dinner Rolls

7 Rolls for $18

Perfect addition to your holiday meal! Yeast roll with a hint of sweetness, brushed with butter and salt

Jumbo Blueberry Muffins

4 for $16

Baked Cinnamon Sugar Doughnuts

1/2 Dozen $15 One Dozen $29

Nutmeg spiced doughnut rolled in cinnamon sugar

Cinnamon Rolls

$25

A yeast roll with a layer of cinnamon and sugar slathered with creamy, sweet icing. Eight rolls in one order.

Lemon Blueberry Scones

4 for $17 or 8 Mini for $17

Topped with a lemon glaze

Mixed Berry Crumble Pie

32

Pecan Pie

30

Cake Menu

Smash Cake

$35

A simple decorated 4" three layer cake in chocolate or vanilla perfect for one year celebration or photos!

6" Cake

$75+

Final cost determined on design. Serves 8-14

8" Cake

$100+

Final cost determined on design. Serves 16-30

9" Cake

$125+

Final cost determined on design. Serves 24-32

Cupcakes

$45+ / dozen

Minimum of one dozen cupcakes per flavor Final cost determined on design.

Two Tier Cake

$200+

Final pricing based on design. 


Cake Flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

Funfetti

Banana

Pumpkin

Carrot

Coconut

Lemon

Almond

Red Velvet

Marble

Dairy Free Chocolate

Dairy Free Vanilla

Egg Free Chocolate

Filling

Add $5 per filling

Lemon Curd

Raspberry Preserves

Cookies N Cream

Caramel 

Chocolate Ganache

Salted Caramel

German Chocolate (coconut pecan)

Boston Cream

Buttercream Flavors

Vanilla

Chocolate

White Chocolate

Peanut Butter

Cookies N Cream

Lemon

Hazelnut

Mocha

Lavender

Caramel 

Salted Caramel

Strawberry

Cream Cheese 

Dairy Free/Lactose Free Options available for additional charge. NOT A NUT FREE KITCHEN.

Have something else in mind? We would love to create a custom cookie for you! Send us a message!

Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 Allie Cat's Bake Shop - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by